My I-140 was approved, but I haven't received the approval notice?

​

A Practical Approach from a Professional Perspective

​

​

​

Many people going through the U.S. employment-based immigration process ask this question.

​

“It says ‘Case Was Approved’ for my I-140 online, but I haven’t received the I-797 approval notice. Is this okay?”

​

To put it simply, in most cases, this isn’t a critical issue.

This is because, in current practice, the “approval record in the USCIS system” serves as a more important criterion than the “physical approval notice itself.”

​

In this column,

- Why this phenomenon has become more common,

- the system that allows NVC and DS-260 processing to proceed even without the approval notice,

- What key points you need to keep in mind in practice.

​

​

​

​

1. Why does it seem like the I-140 approval notice is arriving later and later—or not at all?

​

(1) Internal Backlogs and System Issues at USCIS

In recent years, USCIS has

- an increase in the total number of applications received

- an excessive workload relative to staffing and budget

has led to a clear trend of prioritizing “review and approval” over other tasks.

​

As a result,

- even though approval decisions have already been made in the system,

- there are delays in printing and mailing approval letters, or

- Cases where it appears that some applications have effectively been overlooked

are being reported on an ongoing basis.

​

In other words, it is becoming increasingly common for a case to appear as “Approved” in the online case status system, yet for the paper approval notice to arrive significantly late for the applicant and their attorney.

​

(2) USPS (U.S. Postal Service) Delivery and Loss Issues

Even when approval letters are mailed, due to U.S. postal conditions,

- excessive delivery delays

- Returns

- Loss

and other issues may occur.

​

In particular, categories with high application volumes, such as the EB-3 Unskilled and Skilled categories, experience a higher volume of mail, which increases the likelihood of minor mailing incidents.

​

(3) Increase in the Proportion of Electronic Approval Notifications (e-Approval)

In some cases,

- email notifications

- Online case status updates

—electronic notifications (e-Approval)—play a virtually pivotal role, while the mailing of paper approval notices is often pushed to the back burner or, from the applicant’s perspective, may “feel as if it never arrived.”

​

Therefore, in practice,

the premise that “if an approval notification was received via email and the status shows ‘Case Was Approved,’ the approval itself is recognized” is becoming an increasingly common understanding.

​

​

​

​

2. The standard for legal validity is “electronic approval,” not a “paper approval notice”

​

(1) What really matters is the USCIS electronic record

The moment “Case Was Approved” appears on USCIS Case Status Online, the petition is already legally approved.

- I-797 Approval Notice: A notice informing the applicant of the approval​

- USCIS electronic decision: The main record that gives rise to actual legal effect

​

Therefore, just because you haven’t received the approval notice does not mean the approval is invalid. Whether the case is marked as “Approved” in the system is a far more important criterion.

​

(2) The NVC operates based on “USCIS transmission data,” not a “copy of the approval notice”

Once the I-140 is approved, USCIS transmits the approval information to the **NVC (National Visa Center, under the Department of State)** in **electronic data format**. Based on this data, the NVC

- Generates a case number

- Assigns an Invoice ID

- Marks the application as ready for DS-260 completion

.

​

During this process, there is generally no requirement for the applicant to submit the original I-140 approval notice to the NVC.

In other words, from the NVC’s perspective, the “approval data transferred from USCIS” is the key factor; the physical approval notice itself is not a mandatory requirement.

​

​

​

​

3. To what extent can the process actually proceed without the I-140 approval notice?

​

Based on practical experience, it is usually possible to proceed to the following steps without the original approval notice.

- NVC case creation

- Completing the DS-260

- Paying the fee

- Uploading supporting documents and background information

- Embassy interview

- Visa Issuance and Entry into the United States

​

(1) NVC and DS-260 Stage

The requirements for the NVC stage are

- Approval information sent by USCIS

- The case number and invoice generated based on that information

—not the physical approval letter.

​

Therefore, it is sufficient to prepare for the process based on “verifying approval online + whether an NVC case has been created.”

​

However,

- For future organization of immigration records

- For internal management with attorneys or agencies

, it is advisable to keep a separate copy of the approval screen capture, the approval notification email, and a scanned copy of the PDF approval letter (if received later).

​

(2) Embassy Interview Stage

Many interview guidelines from U.S. embassies and consulates do not explicitly list the original I-140 approval notice as a required document. Even if it is requested,

- “Bring it if possible”

- “Submit if you have it”​

and similar phrasing, often treating it merely as a supplementary document.

​

In practice,

- Submission of the DS-260

- Case information provided by the NVC

- Other documents related to finances, status, and work history

form the core of the review process, and

It is rare for an interview to be suspended simply because the original I-140 approval notice is not available.

​

However, depending on the style of the consular officer or local staff member, they may ask again whether the petition has been approved for additional verification purposes; therefore,​

- A screenshot of the USCIS online approval screen

- a printout of the approval notification email

will help minimize unnecessary back-and-forth during the interview.

​

(3) Entry into the United States and Issuance of a Green Card

After your visa is issued, at the Port of Entry, CBP (U.S. Customs and Border Protection) will verify your information electronically

- Visa information

- Approval records

.

​

It is extremely rare at this stage to be asked to “present the original I-140 approval notice.”

​

The issuance of a green card is also an administrative procedure based on the electronic records of USCIS and the Department of State, and there is typically no separate process requiring the applicant to submit the approval notice.

​

​

​

​

4. So, is the approval notice completely irrelevant?​

​

Not exactly. However, when asked, “Is it a mandatory document in practice?” the reality is that in most cases, the answer is closer to “no.”

​

Its actual practical uses can be summarized as follows:

​

1. Record-keeping for the applicant and their representative

– It serves as a useful reference for future immigration proceedings, changes to other categories, or status-related reviews.

​

2. Supplementary evidence in exceptional circumstances

– In exceptional situations—such as computer errors, case number mix-ups, or agent mistakes—

it can be used as evidence to prove that “USCIS has already approved this petition.”

​

3. Communication Material for Employers and HR Teams

– When organizing immigration support records internally, a copy of the approval notice serves as simple supporting documentation.

​

To summarize, based on recent practical experience, the approval notice is a “document that is nice to have,” not one “without which the process cannot proceed.”

​

​

​

​

5. Summary: Even if the I-140 approval notice hasn’t arrived, there is only one key point to check

​

Finally, here is a summary of the key points:

– If “Case Was Approved” appears in the USCIS system, legal approval has already taken effect.

– The physical I-797 approval notice is merely a means of notifying you of this fact; it is not the source of the approval itself.

– Most procedures—including those at the NVC, the DS-260 application, the embassy interview, and entry into the U.S.—can proceed based solely on the electronic approval record and NVC data.

– Even if the approval notice arrives late, as long as you have a screenshot of the online approval screen or the approval notification email, there should be no major issues in handling the process.

​

Therefore, even if the I-140 approval notice does not arrive for some time, there is no need to worry excessively and wonder, “Has the approval been revoked?”

A more accurate approach is to assess the progress of the actual process based on the USCIS system status and whether a case has been created at the NVC.